On any given Monday night, more likely than not, you can find me bellied up a at certain north Brooklyn establishment enjoying some happy hour oysters for dinner. In all honesty, I rarely make it for HH anymore, since I’m typically getting my little one bathed and ready for bed during that slot of the evening, these days. But I still make it a point to pop over after the little guy is sawing toothpicks. In the years since establishing this weekly ritual, I have made some friends, namely the gentleman who holds court behind the bar on Monday nights. He, and I have heavily overlapping musical taste and often chat about such. My discovery of this book was a product of one of those conversations.
Like many of the bands I discovered in my youth, the Replacements were already over by the time I was introduced to their music. Notwithstanding the fact that I would never be able to see them play live, I was a fan. I picked up the “Pleased to Meet Me” album on CD at some point, and even followed Paul Westerberg’s solo career for a while after seeing the movie The Singles. But I’ll admit that I didn’t really know much about the band prior to reading this book: “Trouble Boys, The True Story of the Replacements” by Bob Mehr.
The Replacements, or the “Mats” (short for “place mats”) as they called themselves, had a rough (ROUGH!) existence as a band. Their story is not some sort of underdog conquers the world, feel-good, happy ending-type. It is one of self sabotage and wasted brilliance. Just the same, it is an incredible tale. Mehr really gets into the weeds a little more than necessary with some of the peripheral characters, but overall his writing is easily digestible. I had a few stop-starts while reading this book, where I had to put it down for a few weeks during times where I was taking in particularly dark segments of the text. But this book also caused me to revisit the band’s entire catalogue, which is now all very accessible on streaming platforms. If you are a fan of 80s-90s alt rock, I strongly recommend checking this one out.